The Marriage Commitment

I watched a thought-provoking episode of Insight recently which explored the concept of arranged marriage (which I differentiate from forced marriage). The participants who advocated arranged marriage compared the process of arranged marriage with what they described as the Western model of love marriage. Recent research has found that arranged marriage has a divorce rate of 4%, compared with 40% for Western love marriages. Before we read too much into this statistic, we must acknowledge that societies that practice arranged marriage still have strong protective features that work to avoid marriage failure, such as religion and strong family ties. These factors are very similar to those present in previous Western generations referred to in my first post. The participants on Insight suggested that parents are in a much better position to make rational and long-term decisions on the suitability of partners, and that love developed over time, assuming honorable intentions from both partners. Compare this with the process of partner selection in Western love marriages, which is heavily dominated by physical attraction, and heavily influenced by hormonal drives. The proponents of arranged marriage have a valid argument. However, there is a challenge emerging for cultures that utilize arranged marriage, particularly for traditional parents raising children in Western societies. In my clinical practice, I have supported many parents from traditional (usually Asian) cultures who experience tremendous concern and distress because their westernized children are exposed to the less constraining aspects of society and are more likely to suffer relationship breakdown.

I also have extensive experience with Western couples who use love as a measure of a successful relationship. As per the title of the bestselling book by Andrew Marshall, I frequently hear couples express concern because they love but are not in love with their partner. When I ask them what they mean by being in love, they usually refer to the excitement and passion of the first few years of their relationship, and bemoan the reduction of such emotion over time. At the same time, the normal problems of life are arising, which compound the absence of excitement. Such problems include raising young children, the emergence of differences in parenting or religious beliefs, financial difficulties, career pressures, and the effect on family and relationships, as well as life stages such as menopause and children leaving home. Naturally, negative emotions are much more likely to occur during such times, and when compared with the seeming absence of passion, falling out of love becomes an obvious outcome. There are large numbers of couples who believe that falling out of love means the end of the relationship.
So if love is not the bottom line of a successful relationship, then what is? I propose that it is the marital commitment, the agreement that we made when we signed on the dotted line on our wedding day. And while we are on that subject, I suggest that the most important part of the wedding ceremony should be the signing of the register, that part of the ceremony when all the important bits are over, and the audience is entertained while the couple do the paperwork. The couple have stated what they are going to sign up to (the vows), and now they are actually signing such a commitment, but nobody pays much attention. A future post will address this issue in more detail, particularly the need for better-informed consent of both parties regarding the agreement that they are making.
I propose that this agreement is no different to the agreement that we make with a bank when we buy a house. We buy a house because we are sure that it fits our needs at that particular time and for the foreseeable future, and we commit to paying for it and increasing its value and worth. So why is marriage any different? The bottom line is that we are committing ourselves to a future with another person, and from there we express honorable intentions to grow, both together and as individuals, to find all possible opportunities to maintain and explore passion, and to commit to meeting each other’s needs. Despite the ups and downs that may occur, the relationship is not brought into question due to the agreement that we made.
I have already been told, “you are talking about a prison cell”. Not at all! As future posts will suggest, marriage is like buying a house, we can re-make the decision at any time. However, this is a challenging view for today’s society where divorce is to be avoided. In the absence of a successful model to meet this dilemma, and with increasing unhappiness, partners often dissolve relationships with extra-marital affairs. And I hear you say, what about the effects of divorce on children? Stay tuned for further posts.
Recent Posts










